Colts Super Bowl Odds: Tracking the Colts Odds to Win Super Bowl 60

Calli Varner Profile Picture
Fact Checked by Jeremy Botter

Although the 2025-26 season hasn’t kicked off yet, the Colts' Super Bowl odds are live at major sportsbooks. Much of the team’s outlook hinges on who wins the starting quarterback job, Anthony Richardson or veteran Daniel Jones. As the competition plays out in preseason, the Colts are prepping for a tough schedule that includes a Week 10 trip to Berlin to face the Falcons.

Heading into the season, Indianapolis has less than a 1% chance of winning Super Bowl 60. For those odds to improve, one of the quarterbacks will need to take command of the offense early and consistently. We’ll be tracking the Colts’ Super Bowl odds all season long as they shift with each game, injury, and roster move. Indy hosts the Green Bay Packers on August 16 for their second preseason game.

Latest Colts Super Bowl Odds: August 2025

Odds will change throughout the season, but here’s a quick overview of the Colts’ Super Bowl odds and other key betting markets on DraftKings before the season starts:

ā­ļø To Make Playoffs: +210 (32.3% chance)
āŒ To Miss Playoffs: -260 (72.2% chance)
šŸ† To Win AFC South: +370 (21.3% chance)
🄈 To Win AFC & Make Super Bowl: +5000 (1.9% chance)
šŸ„‡ To Win Super Bowl: +12000 (0.8% chance)
šŸ“† Odds Last VerifiedAugust 11, 2025

 

What Are the Colts' Odds to Win Super Bowl 60?

The Colts' odds to win the 2025-26 Super Bowl stand at +12000 on DraftKings. Most Kentucky sportsbooks offer similar lines, but expect these numbers to shift once the season kicks off, especially as the quarterback situation clarifies and early results come in.

What Are Colts' Odds to Make Super Bowl 60? 

Fanatics Sportsbook Kentucky and other major sportsbooks have the Colts listed at +5000 to win the AFC and reach Super Bowl 60. That puts Indianapolis near the bottom of the conference, though early-season momentum could quickly shift those odds.

What Are Colts' Odds to Win the AFC South?

The Colts' odds to win the AFC South are +375, according to bet365 Kentucky. These are the third-longest odds, in front of the Tennessee Titans. The Houston Texans won the AFC South in 2024 and are the current favorites to win in 2025. 

What Are Colts' Odds to Make the Playoffs?

The Colts' latest playoff odds +200 per Caesars Sportsbook Kentucky. At FanDuel, Indianapolis has +172 odds, or a 36.8% chance to make the playoffs for the first time since 2020. The Colts don’t have the strongest odds heading into the season, and in a brutal AFC, Indy has a lot to prove if they want to be in the playoff conversation.

Colts Super Bowl Outlook and Predictions

The Colts are looking to regroup after a disappointing 2024-25 season. They finished 8-9 and still haven’t settled on their quarterback of the future. Will it be Anthony Richardson, whose play was inconsistent last year, or newly signed veteran Daniel Jones? Jones threw for 144 yards in the preseason opener, while Richardson sustained a dislocated pinky.

The first step was retaining head coach Shane Steichen, a decision that drew mixed reactions. Now, the team’s future will depend heavily on how the new roster performs. The Colts have been active in the offseason, adding defensive backs Charvarius Ward and Camryn Bynum, while parting ways with defensive lineman Dayo Odeyingbo and offensive linemen Ryan Kelly and Will Fries. They also signed running back Khalil Herbert, defensive tackle Neville Gallimore, and cornerback Corey Ballentine.

On top of those moves, Indianapolis added some fresh talent through the draft, selecting tight end Tyler Warren from Penn State, defensive end JT Tuimoloau, quarterback Riley Leonard, and running back DJ Giddens.

Colts Super Bowl History

Colts Super Bowl Odds

The Colts have a long history as one of the top NFL teams. But they haven't been as good lately. Below, we broke down everything you need to know about this team's Super Bowl history.

YearRecordSuper Bowl Result
200914-2Lost Super Bowl (vs. Saints)
200612-4Won Super Bowl (vs. Bears)
197011-2-1Won Super Bowl (vs. Cowboys)
196813-1Lost Super Bowl (vs. Jets)

Have the Colts Won a Super Bowl? 

Yes, the Colts have won a Super Bowl. Their most recent victory came in 2006. QB Peyton Manning won his first Super Bowl by defeating the Chicago Bears. This was Manning's only title with the Colts. It was the franchise's first (and only) title since moving from Baltimore to Indianapolis.

How Many Super Bowls Have the Colts Won? 

The Indianapolis Colts have won one Super Bowl, in 2006 against the Bears. The Baltimore Colts won a Super Bowl in 1970. The Colts moved to Indianapolis after the 1983 season.

Have the Colts Ever Been to the Super Bowl?

Yes, the Colts have been to the Super Bowl. Their last appearance was in 2009. The Manning-led Colts lost to Drew Brees and the Saints. They have not made the Super Bowl since that loss.

How Many Times Have Colts Been to the Super Bowl? 

The Colts have made four Super Bowl appearances in their franchise history. They have gone 2-2 across those four appearances. Both the Indianapolis and Baltimore Colts are 1-1 in two games.

Where Can I Bet on Colts Super Bowl Odds?

Many Kentucky betting apps offer markets on the Colts' Super Bowl odds and other futures. Odds will vary greatly between books. FanDuel Kentucky has some of the largest selections of futures bets.

Colts Super Bowl Odds FAQ

Author

Calli Varner

Calli has been an avid sports fan since she can remember. After earning her Bachelor’s degrees from the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism at Arizona State University, she combined her passion for journalism and sports. Calli has covered the NFL, NBA, MLB, NCAAF, college sports, and sports betting for several media outlets.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: